The Lesson in Retail David Jones Might Have Missed: Loyalty Has to Be Earned, Not Inherited

A personal stylist's experience in retail partnerships, customer relationships and the commercial value of trust.
There's a lesson in retail that I think David Jones might have missed. I say that as someone who was actually invited to work with them.
Having worked across fashion, retail, visual merchandising, personal styling and customer engagement for more than 15 years, I've always believed successful retail is about much more than product, price and location.
It's about relationships.
A personal experience with David Jones highlighted for me just how commercially important those relationships are and what can happen when the value of a genuine partnership is overlooked.
An opportunity with real potential
I'm an independent fashion and personal stylist. I had no previous formal relationship with David Jones when a manager approached me with an opportunity to bring my private styling clients into their stores. The concept was straightforward and, commercially, quite clever. I would bring my clients into the Gold Coast and Brisbane stores, utilise their private styling suites, create a premium customer experience and, in turn, generate additional foot traffic and sales for the retailer.
I saw real potential in it. I was genuinely grateful to have been approached and excited by the opportunity. I developed a premium styling offering, incorporating catering and using David Jones branding with their approval. I invested my own time, money and advertising into promoting the experience.
My clients came into the stores, enjoyed the service and, in many cases, spent significant amounts of money. It was an opportunity to introduce customers to a retailer they may not otherwise have visited, while providing them with a personalised experience they valued.
In other words, it had the makings of a mutually beneficial partnership.
Then things took an unexpected turn.
When a partnership becomes a commercial conflict
I discovered that a rewards account had been established in my name, without my knowledge, with points from my clients' purchases being credited to that account. This was particularly problematic because I've always been very clear with my clients about my independence. I don't receive kickbacks or incentives for the products I recommend. Clients pay me for my professional advice, and the trust that comes with that independence is fundamental to my business. I was embarrassed by the situation and immediately contacted the affected clients to arrange for their points to be redirected to their own accounts.
That wasn't the only concern.
David Jones subsequently began marketing directly to those same customers, offering complimentary styling sessions with its own in-house stylists. From my perspective, I'd invested in attracting the customers, brought them into the stores, generated sales and then watched the retailer use the relationship I'd helped establish to market directly against my own business.
After unsuccessful attempts to address the situation, I cancelled my advertising and began directing clients towards alternative styling services. I'm now reluctant to take clients into the store unless there's a specific reason to do so. It's disappointing, because the original opportunity had genuine merit.
A good idea needs good business practices
I want to make an important distinction here. I genuinely believe the manager who originally approached me had good intentions and demonstrated clever commercial thinking. He identified an opportunity to connect an independent styling business with a major retailer, and I remain grateful that he recognised the potential in what I could bring to the business.
The concept itself wasn't the problem. The problem was what happened afterwards.
A good idea needs to be supported by good business practices. And collaboration requires more than an initial introduction, a shared objective or permission to use a logo. It requires respect, transparency, clear expectations and commercial intelligence. You can't invite independent businesses to the table, benefit from their investment and established relationships, and then undermine the very businesses helping you grow.
Independent professionals bring more than customers. They bring credibility, expertise, trust and an established connection with people who value their recommendations.
Those things take time to build. They also have commercial value. A retailer that understands this should recognise that a successful partnership isn't simply about what it can extract from the relationship. It's about what both parties can build through it.
The bigger lesson for the retail industry
I think there's a much bigger lesson here for retail. Your relationships with customers, brands, suppliers and independent business partners aren't incidental to your success. They are fundamental to it.
Customers aren’t just transactions. They're people who choose where to spend their money, develop brand loyalties and want to feel valued. They remember the experience, the service and how a business makes them feel.
Brands aren't just products on a shelf. They're businesses investing in their reputation, distribution and the retailers they partner with. Those relationships need to be nurtured, not taken for granted.
Independent businesses aren't simply convenient avenues for bringing new customers through the door. They're commercial partners with their own investment, expertise, reputation and customer relationships. When you fail to nurture those relationships, when you treat loyalty as something you're entitled to rather than something you have to earn, you shouldn't be surprised when people take their business elsewhere.
Is retail losing sight of what makes people want to shop?
Traditional department stores face enormous challenges. Changing shopping habits, online competition, consumer expectations and the changing role of the physical retail environment have all contributed to a very different retail landscape.
Perhaps we also need to look beyond those external pressures. Perhaps we need to ask whether some retailers have lost sight of what makes people want to shop with them in the first place.
A recognised name, a prestigious location and an impressive history can certainly open doors.
But they don't automatically create loyalty.
David Jones has an extraordinary retail legacy spanning 188 years. That's something worth acknowledging, however, history alone doesn't guarantee a future.
The retailers that will remain relevant are those that understand the value of the relationships behind every transaction … with the people who shop with them and the people who help bring those customers through their doors.
Commercial success isn't just about getting people into your store. It's about giving them a reason to come back, and making sure the relationships that brought them there are worth maintaining.
Loyalty has to be earned, not inherited.

Louise Chambers is an Australian fashion and personal stylist, presenter, MC and creative professional with more than 15 years experience across fashion, retail, media, customer engagement and brand partnerships. Learn more about Louise HERE
.png)


